T.J. Holmes And Amy Robach's Ex-Spouses Andrew Shue And Marilee Fiebig Are 'Thinking About' Marriage

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig are reportedly discussing marriage after dating since 2023, following their divorces from Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes.

Sources say the relationship is serious but unhurried, and the pair now live together. Meanwhile, Robach and Holmes are planning an intimate wedding and have included Shue and Fiebig on a preliminary guest list, though attendance isn't expected.

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes revealed that friendship and humor are key to their relationship, despite differing views on wedding guest etiquette.

Andrew Shue And Marilee Fiebig Plan For Marriage As Their Exes Move To Tie The Knot

According to multiple insiders who spoke to Page Six, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig are quietly discussing marriage.

The pair, who began dating in 2023 after their respective marriages ended, have told friends the relationship is serious, though no formal plans have been made.

While nothing is set in stone, those close to them describe the relationship as stable and intentional, noting that both have been married before and aren't in a rush.

"It's very serious," a source noted, adding, "They're not rushing it. They've both been married before. It is something they're thinking about."

Their romance emerged in the wake of the highly publicized relationship between their exes, former "GMA 3" co-hosts Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes.

As that scandal unfolded, Shue and Fiebig reportedly grew closer, bonding over shared experiences.

Andrew Shue And Marilee Fiebig's Romance Was 'Meant To Be' After Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes' Affair

Though Fiebig and Shue had known each other socially through their former partners, they weren't particularly close until then.

Over time, the connection deepened. By last year, Shue and Fiebig had reportedly moved in together.

One source joked that the unexpected pairing felt "meant to be," adding that each person now seems better matched with their current partner.

"Amy and T.J., they're out there. You want the party, that's them," the source said. "Andrew's a lot more chill. They all seem like they've found their partner, ironically."

Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes Plan Intimate Wedding As They Hope For Family Harmony

Meanwhile, Robach and Holmes have reportedly included Shue and Fiebig on a preliminary wedding guest list, though insiders say they don't expect the couple to attend.

According to Us Weekly, there's no pressure or assumption that Shue and Fiebig will be present. Sources added Robach "really wishes they could be a blended and normal family and all get along."

While former partners may be absent, the couple's children will play a significant role in the ceremony. Robach reportedly wants Holmes' daughter, Sabine, alongside her own daughters, Ava and Annie, to serve as bridesmaids.

The wedding itself is expected to be low-key and personal, with no current plans to invite anyone from "GMA." Instead, the celebration will likely include a small circle of close friends and family, totaling roughly 50 to 60 guests.

Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes Say Friendship And Laughter Are The Key To Their Relationship

Speaking with People Magazine at iHeartRadio's Jingle Ball 2025 on Dec. 12, Robach and Holmes shared what they believe has kept their relationship strong. Both emphasized that their foundation is rooted in friendship.

"Friendship, the foundation of friendship, period, point blank," Holmes said, with Robach quickly agreeing. He explained, "If you got a friend you love and you respect ... you end up in a relationship that's still the foundation of friendship."

Robach added that humor plays a huge role as well. "If you can laugh with someone, you can live a long time with someone. You can get through almost anything if you can laugh together." Holmes playfully echoed her point with a "he he," to mimic laughter.

Amy Robach And T.J. Holmes Clash Over Wedding Guest List Rules

However, the two don't always agree, especially when it comes to wedding planning. During an "Ask Amy & T.J." segment with Yahoo News, the couple revealed differing opinions on guest list etiquette. The topic came up after a viewer asked for advice on wedding invitations.

Holmes was firm in his stance, saying, "Don't have anybody at your wedding that you need to be introduced to." When Robach, 52, asked if that meant guests wouldn't be allowed to bring unfamiliar plus-ones, Holmes didn't hesitate to agree enthusiastically, saying: "150%."

Robach pushed back, pointing out that guests are often close friends or family and may want to enjoy the day with their partner.

Holmes, however, questioned why he should invite anyone "for the sake of their feelings" on his wedding day? prompting a visibly surprised reaction from his fiancée as she retorted: "Because you have a relationship with them and you want them to have a good time too."